ADVERTISEMENT

I cannot say it plainly enough: I don’t like Inter Miami. And you don’t have to either. In a league built on parity, budgets, and supporters who ride with their clubs through the cold years, Miami is the shiny exception. They’re the team that bends the rules like Beckham, buys the nostalgia act to build a fanbase, and then hogs the spotlight. It’s not a stretch to say they’re the Manchester City of MLS, if you swap oil funding with construction/telecom money. Rooting against them isn’t bitterness. It’s a moral stance with receipts.

Inter Miami. A contractual thang

Let’s go back to the beginning. When David Beckham made his highly publicized move to LA Galaxy, the MLS changed their strict salary cap rules by implementing the Designated Player Rule (a.k.a. The Beckham Rule). What was less known, but far more consequential, was Becks was guaranteed a MLS franchise for a flat rate of $25M if he met certain conditions. Which he did. In 2014 he selected Miami as his preferred location, plunked down the cash, and wham! The seeds of Inter Miami CF were sown. FWIW, the franchise price at that time exceeded $100M. Beckham and his investors got a ridiculous bargain, and the club’s very foundation was in lockstep with backroom wheeling-n-dealing.

Scandal before success

Fast forward six years, and Inter Miami was finally up and running as the 25th MLS franchise. In short, that debut season was a debacle. Sure, COVID can take some of the blame, but not all of it. The head coach, Uruguay’s Diego Alonso, lasted one year and had a win percentage of 29.2%. The roster was a Frankenstein construction with “big” names way past their prime. Matías Pellegrini, Gonzalo Higuaín and Blaise Matuidi, anyone?

Then came the kicker. MLS discovered the club had effectively carried four designated players when only three were allowed. They hid Matuidi’s real wages and underreporting salaries for three more players. The league hit them with a record $2 million fine, docked owner Jorge Mas $250,000, and stripped over $2.2 million in allocation money. It’s much more than an expansion hiccup, this was a full-on cheating scandal. The club hadn’t even finished their second season.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Messi-ah Cometh

Still, the Herons built a following and suffered through two losing seasons, plus a quick first round exit from the 2022 playoffs. But in July 2023 Lionel Messi, the world’s greatest player, left Paris Saint-Germain for Miami. Along with his massive entourage (he brought over former Barcelona teammates Sergio Busquets and Luis Suárez for big money) came soccer’s greatest reboot.

Miami didn’t qualify for the playoffs in 2023, but they did win their first trophy: the Leagues Cup. And something else got lifted as well: prices. Average ticket costs jumped 500% after his arrival. Season ticket prices nearly doubled from $485 to $884 for the cheap seats. It was a backhanded “thank you” to the faithful that sat through those lean years. 

Inter Miami wasted no time taking this show on the road, but frequently ended up leaving paying customers stranded. 40,000 fans in Hong Kong bought tickets costing nearly HK$5,000 to watch Messi, who never left the bench. He played days later in Japan, and promoters were forced to refund 50%. Vancouver fans who paid $300 to $600 for tickets saw none of Messi, Suárez, or Busquets when the stars skipped the trip entirely. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Money can buy you success… sort of

Let’s talk money, cause there certainly is a lot of it flowing in and out of Inter Miami. Since Messi’s arrival Inter Miami has carried the largest payroll of any MLS team. The latest salary data released by MLS has their current total at $58,359,000 (that’s $18m higher than #2 Chicago Fire). Messi of course is the highest paid player, with a guaranteed salary of $28.33 million. That figure is more than the TOTAL roster salary of 25 of the 30 MLS clubs. That’s parity for you. 

And with that largesse has come hardware. In 2024 the club set a MLS record for season points (74) as they won the Supporter’s Shield. Widely anticipated to win the Cup, they suffered an ignominious elimination to lowly Atlanta United, who finished ninth in the Eastern Conference. They were also knocked out of the CONCACAF Conference Cup and the Leagues Cup early as well, eliciting a “womp womp” from hatewatchers like myself.

Of course, the Shield was enough to entice FIFA’s own Dr. Evil, Gianni Infantino, into filling the Club World Cup’s “host country” slot with Messi… er… Miami. MLS Cup winners LA Galaxy got to watch the event from home. To their credit, Miami was the only MLS team to advance out of the group stage, though their abject humiliation at the hands of Paris Saint-Germain was only mitigated by their opponents essentially ceasing to attack after going up 4-0. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Then there was the 2025 Leagues Cup fiasco. In the final against the Seattle Sounders, which they lost 3-0, Sergio Busquets was caught on camera throwing a punch at Obed Vargas. After the final whistle Luis Suárez was filmed spitting on a Seattle staff member. While Miami would win the MLS Cup that year, episodes like this prove that money doesn’t buy class.

Final Thoughts

So go ahead, enjoy their free-flowing soccer. It can be beautiful to watch. Bask in the awesomeness of the GOAT. He is singularly awesome. That’s your right. But for me, I prefer clubs that follow the rules, respect supporters’ wallets, and don’t spend their way into trophies. I’ll be cheering for the other one.

Inter Miami will host Columbus Crew at NU Stadium in the first leg of the MLS Cup Playoffs on Saturday. Kickoff is at 6:00pm ET / 3:00pm PT. Watch on AppleTV.

ADVERTISEMENT
×