ADVERTISEMENT

There’s good news and bad news for Thomas Frank.

The good news is he’s back at work at the Premier League. The bad is that it’s with the worst team in the division currently, one that is useless at both ends of the field.

The Pierre Sage experiment at Crystal Palace is done. Seven points from 10 games. Bottom of the Premier League and 24 goals conceded, more than anyone else. Twenty-first in the Europa League table. Its star players, Jean-Philippe Mateta and Ismaïla Sarr, want out. As we discussed on We Called it Soccer First podcast, Sage’s previous club, League 1’s Lens, wasn’t just in a different class compared to the Premier League, it’s a different planet.

It’s going to take every bit of Frank’s managerial skills to prevent Palace from sliding into the Championship.

ADVERTISEMENT

A reputation built at Brentford

Frank’s reputation is built in west London. He arrived at Brentford as an assistant, took charge in 2018, and over seven years as head coach turned a Championship club with little history at that level into a regular, overachieving top flight team.

Promotion via the 2021 play-off final was the headline, but the more impressive part was what came next. Brentford stabilised in their first Premier League season, finished ninth in 2022-23 and kept finishing in the top half despite losing key players and, at one point, their main striker, Ivan Toney, to an eight month ban for breaching betting rules.

The model he built was smart recruitment, set-piece excellence, a compact and aggressive shape, and a squad that overperformed its wage bill. His Brentford sides were hard to beat and good at turning small margins into points. That is the Frank Palace will hope to get.

ADVERTISEMENT

A then-disaster at Tottenham

It was with praise ringing in his ears and a hero’s send off that Frank left for Tottenham Hotspur. Eight months later he was sacked, with Spurs sitting 16th in the table and winless in eight league games. His return of 29 points from 26 league games was the lowest points-per-game of any Tottenham manager with five or more matches in the Premier League era, according to Opta. Spurs also scored just 36 goals and created few chances, with injuries to creative players such as James Maddison hurting them.

At one stage he had a very public falling out with Djed Spence and Micky Van de Ven after they refused his orders to clap the crowd after yet another miserable defeat.

Of course there were mitigating factors. Injuries were heavy and the squad was unbalanced. Frank was also not helped by the expectation to suddenly play expansive, high-tempo football at a club whose supporters had grown tired of caution and whose players, frankly, didn’t have it in them.

ADVERTISEMENT

He took Spurs into the Champions League last 16 by finishing fourth in the league phase. But the lasting image is of a manager who struggled to get his team going and who never won over the crowd. A sizeable amount fans simply never accepted he came from a smaller club like Brentford.

The upside is that Palace are much more like Brentford and much less like Spurs, which should suit his skillset well.

Selhurst shambles

It’s painful to see how far Palace have fallen in such a short space of time. Only 18 months ago they were celebrating winning the FA Cup for the first time in their history. That was quickly followed by a Community Shield victory over Liverpool and then, last season, victory in the Europa Champions League.

ADVERTISEMENT

Oliver Glasner, the manager who delivered the lot, left for Nottingham Forest, while despite interviewing Frank, chairman Steve Parish opted for the inexperienced Sage, buying him out of his Lens contract. It was an expensive gamble, and one that has failed spectacularly.

In the last year and three months, they lost Ebereche Eze in attack, and Maxence Lacroix, Mark Guéhi and Joachim Andersen in defense. In their place came two loan signings, Axel Disasi and Honest Ahanor. Sage reportedly fell out with the board over the failure to sign adequate replacements.

Up front, Mateta is back after missing much of the season with injury. Same with Sarr. But both have the spectre of wanting to leave hanging over them and their current understudies are nowhere near their level.

Frank also has the Europa League to juggle, which makes a thin squad thinner and leaves little time on the training ground.

ADVERTISEMENT

Palace fans hope to see an immediate defensive improvement at Saturday’s away game against Coventry, who are already relegation rivals.

Priorites? Both ends of the pitch!

A manager can improve shape and discipline, but he cannot magic up quality centre halves. This will be Frank’s number one area to strengthen in January window, and he must hope they haven’t been cut adrift by that stage. Keeping hold of USA international Chris Richards is a must, and he needs to bring in some quality around him.

Likewise, up top he needs to find a proper number 9 replacement for Mateta, although the Frenchman might stay until the summer if he decides he wants to see how life is under the new boss. Jørgen Strand Larsen and Eddie Nketiah aren’t going to keep you up.

Frank has signed a two and a half year deal, which will include demands to get Palace back to the Premier League should they succumb to relegation this season.

ADVERTISEMENT

How will it go?

Frank should be able to get a better tune out this set of players than Sage did. The midfield pair of Daicha Kamada and Adam Wharton are decent, and if Frank can get Yeremy Pino and Sarr firing together they will present a creative goal threat.

The problem is Palace have a paper thin squad and are low on quality. First job will be to bring some defensive structure, set-piece work and fill the gaping holes that every Premier League team has enjoyed exploiting. That might take a little time, and time is something he hasn’t got loads of.

That said, the bottom half of the Premier League table is congested – only 5 points separate the bottom nine teams – and if he can conjure up a couple of wins and draws in upcoming games, Palace could be out of the relegation zone with January incomings to look forward to.

In the appointment announcement, Frank said Palace were an “iconic club in the Premier League”. He’s got some challenge to keep them there. But he’s an excellent coach with proven credibility with this sort of challenge. I think he will.

ADVERTISEMENT

×